Dragon Age II is a phenomenal game. So much so that I contemplated whether or not I would consider it my favorite game of all time. Then I went on thinking and trying to decide what my top 20 games of all time would be.
My results are based off of a mixture of a lot of things, but it ultimately comes down to my emotional attachment to the game. After all, this is a list of my top 20 favorite games, not necessarily the "best" 20 games, but the games that I hold most dear.
The results are as follows. The top 10 are ranked, the tail 10 are alphabetical:
Goof Troop
Goof Troop is on here because of my cousin Mike. I loved playing this game when I was visiting him and we would always have a blast just goofing around in it (see what I did there?). It was a fun puzzle-action game in the vein of Zelda sans sword.
Kingdom Hearts 2
A sequel to one of my favorite games. There was simply something so enchanting about the series; but I'll get to that later.
Little Nemo
This game is the ultimate reminder of how awe inspiring a game was to me when I was younger. It was and still is an extremely difficult platformer. I remember how proud I would be to beat the first level, and even more so when I got to the second! I still don't think I've beaten the third...but I can't be certain. At least I couldn't the last time I tried.
The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker
I can still vividly remember the opening sequence to this game and the music that accompanied it. It was phenomenal. Then the game started, and I was enchanted.
Mario 64
Nothing will ever be quite like the first time I ran around as a 3D polygonal Mario. Or shot him out of a cannon. Or used the winged hat. Or did a triple jump.
Mario Kart: Double Dash!!
The game that introduced me to the Warp Pipe online community. An online community that I still hold dear to this day long after its death.
Pokemon Blue
Gotta catch 'em all! Pokemon wasn't just a game. For 11 year old me it was a way of life! My cousin Michael and I would get together, play the card game, watch the cartoon, link our games up. The cards, the show, the game, thinking about them brings up warm fuzzies of childhood.
Punch Out!!
This game, like Little Nemo, seemed able to equate prowess at game playing to which boxer you eventually lost to. I personally have never beaten Mr. Dream (I never played the Mike Tyson version). I never even reached him until I grew up a bit and was more coordinated and skilled at gaming. Facing him for the first time was one of the most intense feelings of dread and fear I've felt in a video game. Not scary, obviously, but nerve-wracking as hell.
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
KotOR changed what I knew about video games. Moral choices were introduced. Choices themselves were introduced. Linear story lines that have no baring to what you've done previously or how you've played now feel empty. Games, thanks to KotOR's example, became a medium that could tell a story in a way no other media could.
Super Smash Brothers: Melee
Just a fantastic, frenzied good time. So many characters and items that every match was a complete blast and with the right group of friends, this game simply never got old.
10. Dragon Age: Origins
Dragon Age: Origins re-introduced me to the world of video gaming. I had been on a lull, only playing games on very rare occasion, and not really being excited to play or looking forward to any on the horizon. Origins changed all that. I found a deep, engrossing storyline and game play replete with choices, characters, and narrative to spare.
9. Final Fantasy XI
Yes, an MMO. The time I spent playing this was exhilarating. I really felt like I was someone else in a different world while playing this, as lame and creepy as that sounds. I had fun exploring this new world and getting to know it. This is one that isn't on the list because it was groundbreaking or traditionally fantastic. It just gave me that happy feeling.
8. Super Mario Brothers 3
Nothing will compare to the times I've had playing SMB3 with my sister. Our countless attempts to beat the game have always been thwarted, but that doesn't mean we'll ever stop trying.
7. Tiger Woods PGA Tour 2003
Another game on here because of the memories I have of it playing with my sister. It was always fun to pick up a controller and spend the afternoon on the virtual links with the air conditioning on a hot summer day.
6. Heavy Rain
A video game that is truly an interactive movie. I mean those words as a compliment of the highest regard. I loved the story, the characters, and yes, the short play time. They made the most of those hours, nothing felt dragged out. Also the fact that you could essentially "act" in a scene--lean up against a dresser as someone is telling you something; perch on the bedpost, stand up again, pace--is fantastic and something I've not seen before.
5. The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
What can I say about Oblivion that's not already been said? It was the most engrossing virtual world I had ever come in contact with at the time, and it very well may still be so. You can spend hours, days, and not even touch the main storyline. Just talking and helping out random strangers with their problems and exploring the unknown was endlessly satisfying. The moment I started piecing together the fact that I had become a vampire--people were treating me differently, I was being hurt by the sunlight, then, horrified, I fed on a sleeping person--I knew that this game was something special.
4. Final Fantasy VII
My first real RPG, the first game I'd experienced with such a narrative, the fantastical worlds, characters, plot-twists, music, locations, and emotional resonance. The battle system was tight and exciting. The non-traditional fantasy setting was intriguing and new to me. Moral ambiguity came in full view. Three discs. This game was awe-inspiring, and I loved every moment of it--blocky graphics and all.
3. The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
I almost don't think I need to write anything here about the game--just my experience with it. I had never played it until I received the demo disc that came from pre-ordering Wind Waker. I played it on a tiny television off to the side of the room where my family's television was, and played it while the rest of my family was watching TV. Yet the tiny screen, quiet sound, and playing it almost exclusively laying on my stomach with my head tilted back to see the screen did nothing to detract from the perfection that is this game.
2. Kingdom Hearts
Every once in a while a game will come along that just clicks for you. There's nothing you can necessarily put your finger on, but it digs a hole in your heart so deep that you will never tear it free and would never want to. Kingdom Hearts is this game for me. The theme of Traverse Town will still to this day make my stomach ache and long out of love for this game.
1. Dragon Age II
Yes, Dragon Age II tops this list. The game play was fun and slick, the characters were intensely deep and satisfying, the dialogue was fun and endearing, and the storyline was varied and unexpected as it was needed and daring. Dragon Age II took the series in a much-needed direction. After Origins, there wasn't much left to say. We defeated the blight--yay! But Dragon Age II created a change in the very world, something that many series don't dare to do. The moral choices you had to face in this game were beyond anything ever before. There was one moment where I stared horrified at the screen being forced to make an impossible decision. I refused. I stared at the screen a good five solid minutes hoping that one of my companions would swoop in and decide for me. They didn't, of course, and I was forced to make the decision for myself. And I didn't feel good about it afterward. It left an actual impression on me--one that followed me after the credits rolled and made me think about my decision afterward. Did I make the right choice? The fact that this game can even do that shows just how phenomenal it was. Hawke, a crowning achievement, is probably the deepest, most well-developed and believable protagonist in any game. Not to mention he's a complete bad-ass.